Can I Trust My Conscience to Tell Me Right from Wrong?
Ministries > Focal Point with Pastor Mike Fabarez
A tree never loses sleep over something it did; it simply follows its programming. Pastor Mike Fabarez probes the one part of you that weighs nothing, can’t be seen, and still knows how to land a punch: your conscience.
Announcer: Today on Focal Point with Pastor Mike Fabarez.
Mike Fabarez: You want your conscience to be like the Apostle Paul's conscience and say, I have a good conscience. At the end of the day, when you lay your head down on a pillow, it'd be good for you to say, my conscience is clear, it is not condemning me, there's no duplicity in my life. I have
Guest (Male): this
Mike Fabarez: thing
Guest (Male): that we often call integrity. We have a sense that my conscience is clear, that I'm doing things the way God said I should, both in action and motive, and Paul says, I have this.
Announcer: Shakespeare gave us Lady Macbeth scrubbing at hands that would never feel clean. Edgar Allan Poe gave us a narrator undone by a heartbeat beneath the floorboards. But no one needs great literature to know what a guilty conscience feels like. Nearly all of us have felt it, perhaps even this week. Today on Focal Point, Pastor Mike Fabarez launches a new series from 2 Corinthians called A Clear Conscience, and builds a case that God wrote his moral law on every human heart. Here's Pastor Mike with Knowing Our Absolute Standard.
Mike Fabarez: Well, you may not think about it very often, but you are very unique to be here in this world as a human being and not a tree or a rock or a cat. You were the pinnacle of God's creation, a day six craftsmanship. It's the only thing the Triune God said about his material creation, that you're created in his image, which of course he's spirit. This is not about your physical features, it's about your ontological features, who you are as a being. And that's a big deal, because if you were a tree, all you'd do all day is just, by impulse, let those biomechanical functions fire away based on the coding of your DNA that God created, and you'd be shoving those roots into the ground, and they would be in search of water. It's called hydrotropism, which you wouldn't know because you don't think, you don't reason, you're just a tree. But they would be searching, especially as they got bigger, to support your life. They would be searching for minerals. They would twist and turn in search of potassium and nitrogen and all the things they need to nourish your, the wood of your tree. You would need all of that going below ground, and then above ground you would have your branches going out, and they would be, of course, reaching out to try and convert this light energy into chemical energy and something called photosynthesis, which, of course, you wouldn't know that word either. It'd just be a thoughtless process of your leaves sprouting and trying to grab as much sunlight and carbon dioxide as possible to convert it to glucose so it might feed you and, you know, produce oxygen for the rest of the ecosystem. That's what you would do, and it would be what you wanted to do because that's how you're programmed. And actually, you'd be living by the old 1960s and 70s adage of if it feels good, do it. That's all you would do. It would feel good and you would do it. That's what trees do. They just do whatever they're programmed to do, and that's how they live. That's how you'd live every day, every hour for the rest of your life until you as a tree died. But you're not a tree, and you're a human being, and you can reflexively think and reason and make decisions. And a lot of people in the 60s and 70s made the decision that we should all live by that mantra, if it feels good, do it. But I hope you realize that everyone who said that never lived by that. I mean, they did things that traditional Christians and others that were moralists said you shouldn't do, but they didn't do whatever they felt like doing. take, for instance, standing in the modern era behind a big construction worker at an ATM machine who pulls out a bunch of hundreds, lays them there on that little tiny counter in front of the screen, and you would want to have a few extra hundred dollars in your pocket. That would be nice, but you wouldn't take them for fear, I trust, if you're a rational being, that you might get beat up by a big 220 pound construction worker. You would leave the money right where it's at. You'd want to do it, but you'd think, no, rationally, that's not smart. I don't want to do this because there are consequences. Well, there's a part of who we are that we don't think about as often as we should. I'd like to think about it for the next five weeks. It's something that doesn't weigh 220 pounds. It's weightless, it's invisible, but it's built into who you are as a person made in the image of God, as someone that God has designed, who has a kind of distinction from the rest of creation that can tell you not to do something, and if you do it, it can give you a beating, a great beating, such a beating that in literature it's talked about all the time, as King Claudius is convicted by the guilt from his conscience, as Hamlet, as you might remember, creating the play to convict his uncle of what he had done, and of course he trembles in fear because, of course, he's guilty, or better yet, maybe Lady Macbeth, who was involved in murder, kind of the Jezebel of Shakespeare's literature, and of course, she is so guilty that she starts sleepwalking at night, trying to wash her hands from the blood guilt of killing, and she just can't get past the fact that her conscience is beating her up. Or maybe, speaking of literature, that short story you had to read by Edgar Allan Poe. Do you remember that one? Telltale Heart, where, here is the unnamed narrator who's getting berated and beaten by this conscience of his because, though he's gotten away with this murder, of course he really hasn't because his conscience is doing a number on him. You might not know literature as well as others, but you don't need to read to know that you've had your own battles with your own conscience. Perhaps even this week, your conscience has beat you up for something you've done. And certainly, as I think about the totality of your life, you don't have to be very old to look back at your life and know that your conscience has probably beaten you pretty hard over something you did, maybe something that no one else even knows about. The conscience, that's something trees don't have, dogs don't have it, right? I mean, the created world doesn't have, but you are unique as a rational, reflexive, intelligent person made in the image of God. He's given you this thing that stands there as an alarm system for doing what you do. I'd like to think about this from a biblical perspective, look at the limitations, some of the faults, and some of the important things that we ought to do in relation to your conscience, how to live with your conscience. And I think this great section of 2 Corinthians will help us in this. All the rest of chapter 1, verses 12 to the end of the chapter, and even into chapter 2, as we look at Paul explaining a little bit of his change of plans. If you have your Bibles, I want you to turn to this because it can teach us a lot about how you should live with your conscience. And you need to think about this because, even as Paul here is writing a letter having to defend himself from his critics, he's writing to an audience that has had a lot of people saying to them the Apostle Paul should not be listened to. Now, this is a bad guy and you shouldn't trust him. And of course, it didn't help that his plans had been changed about a visit that he had planned. And so a lot of the translators have put above this paragraph starting in verse 12 of chapter 1, Paul's change of plans, or he explains his change of plans, or whatever it might be, he's about to get into all of that. But he makes an interesting statement here in verse number 12 that I want to use as just the top theme of all that we're going to deal with as he kind of works through the misunderstandings and all the other things that happen in this section of scripture. But I think we need to think a little more systematically about what the Bible would say regarding the conscience. Now, maybe if you dig deep into people critiquing the Bible, you might have heard that, Paul is just adopting a lot of the philosophy of the Hellenists at this particular time, and he's incorporating a lot of things about the conscience that really aren't biblical, but that couldn't be further from the truth. Matter of fact, though the word you're not going to find as ubiquitous in the Old Testament as we see Paul using it in his letters, this isn't because he's introducing something new. This has all been under the heading of something in the Old Testament called the heart. And the idea of the heart and the rational features of the heart, having the heart respond to your volitional decisions is all that Paul is doing and taking the word of that particular era that survived our day. Of course, the translation of it that we use the word conscience, and you know it's a good way for us to categorize that aspect of your life, of all that's going on in your heart when you make decisions, or when you stop from making a decision, or maybe when you are willing to do what Paul is doing here, and that is to justify a decision that you've made because your conscience is testifying within your own heart. So let's look at this as we think about the internal thoughts that we have, the control center of your mind, the way you think, the ontology of being a human being, a rational human being, a reflexive human being, someone who can think about decisions and make decisions, right? We, I hope, most of you at least, sit here this morning as Christians, and you'd like to make good decisions because that's what God has called you to do as a child of God, to make good decisions in this world, where your conscience has a very important role to play in this. And I want to just begin our five-week series on the conscience and using Paul's life as an example for us. I want to just start this morning with just verse number 12. So let's study that this morning. I'll read it from the English Standard Version. You follow along here in 2 Corinthians chapter 1 verse 12. Paul says, for our boast is this. Now remember, this is Paul and Timothy here. That's at least the identified speakers in this. That's why it's first person plural. Our boast is this, the testimony of our conscience. There's the word. We could get into the etymology of the word. I don't think that's super helpful at this particular point, but the idea of a word that gives us some kind of integrated harmony between what I've decided and what I think is right and what my conscience is saying is right. This internal part, this barometer, this temperature gauge, this alarm system telling me that what I've done is right. And this is the testimony of my conscience. I'm happy that this is the case. I'm proud. I can boast about this, that my conscience alarms were not going off. Here it comes, that we behaved in the world with simplicity and godly sincerity, not by earthly wisdom. So whatever it was that he means by simplicity and godly sincerity is not like the rest of the world functions, but he says that's the way it has worked in my mind, in my conscience, in my behavior. So the decisions that I made, my behavior, my conscience is saying is the right behavior, and I know it because he uses this adverb here, godly. It's something that has been done properly. And it may be that you're reading a translation, by the way, that doesn't have the word simplicity, or you're reading the ESV, you look at the footnote there, and you see that it says some manuscripts say holiness. Now, usually these are easy to decide between, but this is a very difficult one because these two words, simplicity and holiness, they sound a lot alike, and they're easy to mistake if you were a copyist in the early church, and they're just two letters apart. And this word holiness that many translations translate from the manuscript evidence of the early church is certainly something that would fit the context, but sincerity is a word that Paul uses a lot in 2 Corinthians, and so many people would choose that this is really what Paul wrote. Usually I don't even bring up these textual variants, but in this case, it's a hard one to decide between. This word holiness, at least the way it's used here, the form of it Paul's never used. so some people say, well, I don't think it's that. That's why the ESV translators, a very recent translation, say it's the word simplicity. Either way, it's all governed by this genitive form of God, of God or godliness, which means that whatever this is, if it's simplicity, a word he does use later, that he's trying to get them to have this simplistic or this sincere or this unified devotion to God. I want to think about this being united in motive and behavior and thought and decision. All of this is what Paul is arguing for. So either word fits the context, but I can say whatever the variant should be in this case, it's something that fits the biblical model. It is godly, it is right, it is biblical, and it's not of earthly wisdom. Now, how does he credit this? Well, it's not just because I'm a great person and I always have a clear conscience, and my conscience is always in sync with my behavior, but he says it was by the grace of God. It's by the grace of God that I'm not doing it like the world's doing it, which we should always remember. And what is just amazing that he says here about the Corinthians, because he's getting a lot of grief from the critics. He says, and supremely so toward you. I mean, I've done this in keeping with a clear conscience and supremely toward you. So there is a little bit of a lean in into his defense. I was going to come there. I didn't come there when I said I was going to come there, and you think it was because my critics are saying I'm a flake and I don't really mean what I say, but that's not true. There's a biblical reason for me not coming to you, and my change of plans, I'm going to explain it. We'll get into all of that. But today, let's just think about this. He's saying, I'm going to appeal not only to the fact that this was godly and right, but my conscience is clear. My motive was right, my behavior was right. This is a good thing, and my conscience attests to this. And all I'm saying as a Christian, if you're a Christian and you have a claim to godliness and you're trying to live a sanctified Christian life, you want your conscience to be like the Apostle Paul's conscience and say, I have a good conscience. At the end of the day, when you lay your head down on a pillow, it would be good for you to say, my conscience is clear. It is not condemning me. There's no duplicity in my life. I have this thing that we often call integrity. We have a sense that my conscience is clear, that I'm doing things the way God said I should, both in action and motive. And Paul says, I have this. So before we dive into this, and it'll become the predicate for all of our series here. And I just want to start with something more of a systematic heading here. Number one, I'd like just for you to understand your conscience. So we're going to have to dip outside of 2 Corinthians chapter 1, but I'd like to think, what does Paul say? What does the Bible say about our conscience? And once you write that down, turn with me to Romans chapter 2, because that's a good place for us to start. And it may be you say, well, I don't need this. It's pretty simple. I know what a conscience is, but let's at least think of it this way. Even as you turn to Romans 2, I'll read it here for you in a second, but let's write this down because here's what we're going to learn in this passage. Your conscience, which is something you have, something you possess, your heart, your spirit, who you are, has got this alarm system here that has been, here's what I'll say, letter A, if you will, it has been encoded, it has been programmed. Initially, it's been programmed by God to comport with his moral law. Now, if I had thought of this ahead of time, I would have made that much more succinct, but you know what I'm trying to say. God has programmed your conscience to be something that will harmonize with what he says in the moral law. Now, Paul here in Romans chapter 2 is talking to the Jews who have the law, and they always look down their long nose at the Gentiles who don't have the law, and they think, look at these guys, they're losers, right? And Paul is about to say to them, not only in the first 13 verses, you don't even keep all the laws that you say you should keep. You have the law, but you don't always keep the law. And now he turns in verse 14 to the Gentiles. So let's look at this to understand something about conscience. For when the Gentiles who do not have the law, right, that's the writing of the Old Testament, particularly the law of Moses, by nature do what the law requires. Now understand that has to be a subset of the law because there's a lot of the law that's all about what foods you can eat, what foods you can't eat, what day you can work, what day you can't work, when the new moon festivals are, and what kinds of ceremonies and feast days you should have. That there's a place called a tabernacle and later a temple, and there's a bunch of people from a particular tribe that are going to lead that, and there's sacrifice you have to bring, and the Aaronic priests that have to wear certain stuff. There's a breastplate for the high priest and a turban on his head and an ephod and all the stuff we just read about in our daily Bible reading. Well, they wouldn't know any of that. But it says here, by nature they do what the law requires. We're not talking about the ceremonies of the Old Testament law, we're talking about the moral law. They're not sleeping with their neighbor's wife at times. They're not stealing from their neighbor at times. I mean, there's always the exceptions, but in those exceptions, they all say, well, we know we're not supposed to do that. Even in the tribal lands of little tiny hamlets somewhere, there's still people that are adjudicating wrong in their tribes because they're saying, that's not right. You shouldn't do that. You shouldn't embezzle. You shouldn't extort. You shouldn't lie, cheat, or steal. So they do by nature the things the law requires, not perfectly, of course, but they are a law unto themselves. They can write their own moral law code, even though they don't have the law. Now, of course, they could never dream up the ceremonial laws, but they can certainly see the moral law. Well, how do they do that? Verse 15. They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts. You want a one-line explanation of what your conscience is, here is what it initially is. It is written by God on your heart, the moral rules of God. God has said inside of you that you have this alarm system where all of the rules of God are. You should not take the construction worker's money, even if he turned his back and he would never see you and you can get away with it and you're never going to get beat up by the construction worker. Your conscience should say, I'm going to beat you up, and you shouldn't do that. That's the moral law of God written on your heart. Now he gives the word that was certainly in vogue in the first century in Paul's readings and teachings and training, while their conscience also bears witness and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them. That's a good line there of what your conscience does. When you know you've done the right thing with the right motive, it can, when people say you've done wrong, it can sit there and give you an excuse. It excuses you. Paul is in the process in 2 Corinthians chapter 1 of giving an excuse, which is not the way we use excuse, like it's just an excuse. No, this is a rational refutation of people saying you've done the wrong thing. He's going to say, no, no, no, no, I've done the right thing, and my conscience is going to attest to the fact that I've done the right thing. So it bears witness. Sometimes it accuses you, you shouldn't have done that. And sometimes it excuses you. Listen, I don't care what people think, this is the right thing. On the day when, according to my gospel, God judges the secrets of men's, of men by Christ Jesus. Now, that last line may be confusing and seem like a interpolation or sometimes somehow just how did that line fly in there? Well, you got to get the larger context. Paul has said repeatedly in chapter 1 that when people sin and they're judged, they do so in sinning and they get judged without any excuses. And he starts with natural theology. God teaches a lot just about his own attributes by nature itself. And now he, this is a reprise of that on a whole different level. In other words, if someone says, no, I didn't know it was wrong for me to lie, cheat, or steal, right? At the day that God brings out all of this evidence and he judges people, the secrets, and there's where your conscience works. It works in the secret places of your own internal operational system, the headquarters of your heart, your volitional center. There is something secret there that no one else can see called your conscience, and God will say your conscience told you you were wrong. I don't care if you're the Aborigine in the outback of Australia or some, some, you know, person in Erie and Gaya, and you've never seen a church, you've never heard about the gospel, you've never read the Bible. If you stand before God and you say, I shouldn't be punished because I've been good, God's going to judge the secrets of your heart, and he'll say, what's up, what about this thing I, this alarm system I gave you, you knew it was wrong. Before you reached out and grabbed that stack of hundreds at the ATM, so to speak, right, you knew it was wrong. And I coded you this part of you, your life, this accusation of your life or this exoneration of your life, this thing called a conscience. I've programmed it. And so I'll bring all that to the surface to speak against you. I will call in as a witness your very own conscience, so you're without excuse. Well, okay, so he's dealing with two different things here in the passage, the immediate issue of the Pharisees and then the larger context of everyone is a sinner, which, reaches its fever pitch in chapter 3. Conscience. What is it? God has put the law. What kind of law? The moral law of God on your conscience. He's originally programmed it that way. Okay? That's why you can see this even evident in toddlers' lives. You start to see this conscience. Here's the problem. Go to 1 Corinthians chapter 4. Paul had written this in the first book to the Corinthians, talking about stewardship here, and I got to be faithful, verse 2, you know, and I know that you guys might stand in judgment of me, and I might even be called before the Roman courts, but you know what? It's not the end all. He's going to get to the last line of verse 4. It is the Lord who judges me. At the end of the time, he's going to say it's all about what does God think? And that's where we try to get, you know, in the largest sense, in largest scheme, at the end of every sermon, what does God think of your life?
Announcer: You've been listening to Focal Point and the opening message in Pastor Mike Fabarez's new series, A Clear Conscience. If today's teaching would help someone you know, pass it along. It's at focalpointradio.org. Each week of this series builds on today's foundation, so it's a good one to keep. You'll also find it on the free Focal Point app, alongside years of Pastor Mike's verse by verse teaching. Pastor Mike described the conscience as an alarm God built into the human heart. The psalmists knew how that alarm sounds, and they also knew where to run when it went off. In this month's resource, Psalms of Trust, Pastor H. B. Charles Jr. works through 10 psalms from the first verse to the last, showing how God's people have brought their anxieties and burdens before the Lord. It's warm, pastoral, and firmly rooted in the text, less like a commentary and more like a pastor sitting across the table from you. Request Psalms of Trust with your gift to Focal Point this month by calling 888-320-5885 or visit focalpointradio.org. Or if you'd rather mail a gift, send it to Focal Point, Post Office Box 2850, Laguna Hills, California, 92654. Today also marks the start of something special. A generous ministry friend has offered to match every year-end gift to Focal Point up to 250,000 dollars through December 31st. That means your gift, whatever its size, will go twice as far. As we begin nearing the end of the year, this match will help us finish 2026 strong and prepare Pastor Mike's live program, Ask Pastor Mike Live, to answer more questions for more people in 2027, including through a new studio now being built. Give whatever you feel led to today at FocalPointMinistries.org/double or call 888-320-5885. If this is your first visit with us, Pastor Mike has a booklet he'd love to put in your hands, Seeking Comfort, Free of Cost. Request it at focalpointradio.org or call 888-320-5885. Tomorrow, Pastor Mike turns to 1 Corinthians 4, where Paul admits that a quiet conscience doesn't automatically mean a clean record. I'm Dave Drury. We'll see you Tuesday on Focal Point.
Unidentified Speaker: Pastor Mike here. You know, it's an honor to be with you every day, helping you explore the depths of scripture. But I want to be clear, no amount of Bible knowledge is ever going to save you. Be sure where you stand with God. Get in touch with us. We'd love to pray with you and for you. Visit us today at focalpointradio.org. We look forward to hearing from you.
Announcer: Today's program was produced and sponsored by Focal Point Ministries.
Related Episodes
Tithing on a Tight Budget & the Meaning of Foreknowledge
Friday, November 13
What Would Change If I Let Others Walk Through This Season with Me?
Thursday, November 12
Am I Trusting the Tools God Uses More Than God Himself?
Wednesday, November 11
Related Videos
About Focal Point
Focal Point is the Bible teaching ministry of author and pastor Mike Fabarez. Focal Point explores and proclaims the depths of Scripture on its daily radio broadcast and is dedicated to clearly explaining the truth of God’s Word.About Pastor Mike Fabarez
Mike Fabarez is the founding pastor of Compass Bible Church in South Orange County, California and has been in pastoral ministry for more than 30 years. He is committed to clearly communicating God’s word verse-by-verse and encourages his listeners to apply what they have learned to their daily lives.Pastor Mike is a graduate of Moody Bible Institute, Talbot School of Theology (M.A.) and Westminster Theological Seminary in California (D.Min.).
Mike is heard on hundreds of radio programs across the country on the Focal Point radio program and has authored several books, including Raising Men Not Boys, Lifelines for Tough Times, Preaching That Changes Lives, Getting It Right, Praying for Sunday, and Why the Bible?
Mike and his wife, Carlynn, reside in Laguna Hills, California and they have three children, Matthew, John and Stephanie.
Contact Focal Point with Pastor Mike Fabarez
Mailing Address
Focal Point
P.O. Box 2850
Telephone
1-888-320-5885